Bully Sticks vs. Antlers: Which Chew Reigns Supreme?

The ultimate showdown between two natural chew champions.

If you're standing in the chew aisle wondering, "Should I grab a bully stick or an antler for my dog?" — you're not alone. At Summit Dog Chews, we sell both because we know each one plays a different role in your dog's chewing adventure. But which is better? Let’s break it down.

The Contenders:

🦴 Antler Chews: Naturally shed elk antlers, collected from the mountains, cut and sanded into long-lasting chews. Rich in minerals, mess-free, and odorless.
🐂 Bully Sticks: 100% beef muscle, slow-dried to perfection. High-protein, fully digestible, and loved by picky pups.

Chew Factor: Durability

Antlers:
Antlers are built to last. If your dog is a power chewer, these are your MVP. Some dogs will gnaw an antler for weeks or even months without finishing it.

Best for: Dogs who destroy typical chews in minutes. (Check out our Extreme Chewer Collection if that sounds like your pup.)

Bully Sticks:
Softer than antlers and typically consumed in one sitting or over a couple of days, bully sticks are ideal for a quick chewing session that satisfies without overdoing it.

Best for: Dogs who love a treat they can finish—especially as a daily enrichment snack.

Nutrition Showdown

Antlers:
Packed with calcium, phosphorus, magnesium, and other minerals essential for joint, bone, and immune health.

Bully Sticks:
High in protein, low in fat, and fully digestible—great for muscle development and keeping your pup full between meals.

Want to learn more about chew nutrition? We dive deeper in Let Your Dog Chew Wild.

Mess + Smell Scorecard

Antlers:
Completely odorless and leave zero residue. Ideal for indoor chewing.

Bully Sticks:
We offer odor-free bully sticks (you’re welcome), but they may soften and leave a bit of residue. Not a dealbreaker—but maybe skip the white couch.

Price Point

Antlers are more expensive up front, but last significantly longer.
Bully sticks are more affordable but need to be replenished regularly.

Verdict: Who Wins?

Honestly? Your dog.

If you want a long-lasting, mineral-rich chew that’s practically furniture-proof—go with an antler.
If you're after a tasty, protein-rich treat for everyday enrichment—reach for a bully stick.

Many of our customers use both! Some dogs get an antler as a “job” to keep them busy during work calls or crate time, and a bully stick as a treat after a hike or training session.

💡 Not sure where your dog fits in? Our guide Best Chews for Every Chewer Type can help you choose the right product based on your dog’s style.